Loading discussion content. Please wait...
I Have Alzheimer’s or Another Dementia
Disappointing 1 st visit with university memory clinic
I've been diagnosed with MCI by a neurologist and a psycho neurologist after several hours of testing. There are a number of things that could affect my memory, years of taking anti depressants for depression, possible stroke, car wreck where I was knocked unconscious, chronic insomnia and being 74. I thought by seeing seeing "the experts" at a university neurology department, I might find out if there was a reason for my diagnosis other than my fear of starting the long decline into alz.
I was checked into the neurology dept. and put in an exam room. In comes a student with a tag hanging from his chest labeled "student". He tells me he will be interviewing me and will then meet with the doctor and then the doctor will see me. For about 15 to 20 minutes I told this person my concerns listed above and my hope of possibly finding out if there might be other reasons for my memory problems. He leaves and after a while the doctor and the student return. Something got lost in in the translation of my concerns and how the doctor approached the meeting. Nothing was said about my concerns and hopes. It seemed he was more concerned about my getting tested by an occupational therapist for a driving evaluation than anything else. I wasn't really concerned about my driving at this time. I have had in the last 2+ years times where I have been lost on familiar road about 3-4 times. This is momentary, and I shortly remember where I'm at and adjust accordingly. I would say my driving is 99% ok.(no wrecks, bumps or scratches so far, cross my fingers)
Well the short of my 1 st meeting was a mini mental test where I did learn something new. He stated the summary of our meeting that I have " amnesic MCI with memory loss". So I I've now read where MCI has 2 classifications, 1) amnesic MCI (dealing with memory and 2) non amnesic MCI dealing with thinking and decision making.
He made an order to have my driving tested where if I failed he could have my license revoked, an order for an MRI, an order to release records from previous hospitals about the car wreck and possible stroke a and to see him in 6 months. End of session 1. A sleep clinic where I have been going to for my chronic insomnia had prescribed Zolpidem (a generic for Ambien) for my sleep disorder. The doctor said to stop taking it but did not prescribe and would not prescribe another sleep aid, so I felt left somewhat hanging. He may be right on that point, after reading up on sleep meds, I don't think any of them are good for elderly with memory problems. Anyone have an opinion on this or about my experience with this doctor? I'm beginning to think that exercise and diet are probably the best meds to help stave off cognitive decline?
It certainly does not sound as though you got the testing you were hoping for.
From your library, ask for a copy of The Alzheimer's Action Plan by Doraiswamy and Gwytherf of Duke Univ. Compare with the testing you received.
The mini mental test is absolutely not adequate. You need a neuro-psych.
I'm a bit confused, Larry. Did you have a series of sophisticated neurocognitive tests, lasting several hours, before your recent appointment? That's more that the mini mental test. That testing can determine your cognitive status, whether you have MCI or dementia. I think the neurologists feel that they have to do the mini mental at every visit. I know my doctor did, in the beginning. I don't know why, when he had the results of several more complex tests.
I hope the neurologist had reports from your PCP to confirm the absence of treatable medical causes. The sleeping pill zolpidem can impact memory and cognition. I was on a different medication which the PCP discontinued, since it impacted memory. Two years ago I discontinued Lunesta, a sleep aid, and after a withdrawal period, I believe I do notice some improvement in my attention, although my long term memory seems to be worsening. I did not stop the Lunesta cold turkey, but weaned myself off. I use melatonin to supplement my natural melatonin, although it does not act as a sleeping pill.
You're right, exercise and diet as part of Best Practices is the best approach to staving off cognitive decline. Also, reducing other risk factors as much as possible. Following Best Practices is working for me.
You initially asked about joining a clinical trial. If you want to do that, and can, go ahead, as an patient with MCI. You can add to the scientific knowledge base. Otherwise, continue with Best Practices, and follow up with the neurologist when scheduled. You might also work on your legal paperwork, such as POA. Figure out how you can monitor your own progress. That's what I am doing.
Typical experience. I'm sorry to say that it really doesn't matter whether you go to a small neurology clinic or a big university one. Experience is the same. Sleep meds make brain functioning worse. Your insomnia is probably due to your brain function or your circadian rhythm is off (which is also part of the disease). Ambien is also notorious for causing people to do things while still sleeping like eat, drive, go for a walk, etc. I personally never saw any of the ALZ meds work for my mother and believe they are money down a hole but others here feel differently.
There's really no telling what is causing your symptoms. As you already know, the only "real" diagnosis comes on a brain autopsy and while possible stroke and your auto accident are likely, the others aren't as likely.
My personal belief is that the medications such as Aricept and Exelon patch work best the earlier they are begun. They may improve functioning and may prolong the early stages. If they are begun late, their may be limited or no change. I have been on Exelon patch with Namenda for eight years, and I can tell every day that they are making a difference in my life, in the area of maintaining my ability to live independently, and even travel on my own, even though it is getting a little bit harder. Unfortunately, some PWDs are not improved by the medications, given at any time.
I did finish the book- The Alzheimers Action Plan and I'm not concerned about my driving at this point.
I did have about about 4 hours of testing by a neuro psychologist. The Memory Clinic doctor at this university should have had the test results at our 1 st meeting but I guess he didn't. I had them sent but signed a release to have them sent to him. This is why he gave me the mini mental test, I guess. After having a new MRI done, I'm not sure why I would have to wait 6 months to see him again. I don't have much confidence in this doctor.
I've tried melotonin and it didn't do much. I've decided to do something different, I made an appt. with an integrative medical clinic. The doctor is an MD and an internist. They don't accept insurance and I have to pay for it all except maybe for lab test. I've heard good things about this approach so I'll find out.
I'm also thinking about going to a plant based diet. I just found out that processed foods cause cancer. Hot dogs, lunch meat, bacon to name a few. I think this clinic offers help in this area. I was watching a video which said all protein comes from plants. So why do we have to feed protein to animals and then eat the animals to get protein?
Good luck, Larry.
You can get protein from vegetables but you have to investigate. For example, if you eat beans and rice together, you get protein, but not if you eat them alone.
So you need to go on-line and check the protein content of foods you are eating. How much do you have to eat to get 4 grams of protein.
Look for the Mediterranean-MIND diet. You can make it vegetarian if you prefer. Antioxidants are well supplied through fruits and vegetables and legumes.